Why you should reply to all reviews
Sales & Marketing

Why you should reply to all reviews

Using Shopify? Boost conversions & grow your email list in 5 minutes with an AI product quiz. Try it for free 🚀

Try it free

Ever wondered if replying to every customer review is worth the hassle? Spoiler alert: It is, and I’ve got the numbers to prove it.

TL;DR 🎯

Here’s the short version: Reply to all reviews—yep, even the grumpy ones. Why? Because you’ll see more positive reviews, fewer negative ones (but they’ll be longer), and overall, you’ll get more feedback. It’s simple: When customers see you care, they care more too.

Case in point: A study on Texas hotels showed that when they started responding to TripAdvisor reviews, their star ratings bumped up by 0.12 points, and they got 12% more reviews. Plus, those negative reviews? They became fewer, but more detailed. It’s like turning lemons into lemonade—extra sweet and a bit more complex.

Why it works 🤔

Here’s the psychology behind it:

When customers notice you’re paying attention to their feedback, two things happen. First, they’re more excited to leave a positive review because they know it won’t just vanish into the void. Second, they’ll hesitate before dropping a negative one because they know you’re going to read and respond.

Think about it: If someone’s going to throw shade, they’re going to make sure it’s well-constructed. That’s why negative reviews tend to get longer and more detailed. But some folks might just skip the hassle altogether if they’re not up for it.

What to watch out for ⚠️

This study focused on hotels, but the same principles apply to your business. Heads up: the research didn’t specify which types of responses work best, but other studies suggest that thoughtful, personalized replies outperform the generic stuff. So, steer clear of “Thanks!” and “Sorry!” Your customers deserve a little more effort.

How to do it ✅

Here’s how you can make this work for you:

  1. Keep an eye on your reviews: Set up alerts so you can respond within a day or two. The quicker you reply, the more impact your response will have.
  2. Make your responses count: For positive reviews, echo what the customer loved and throw in something extra to show you’re genuinely paying attention. Example: “So glad you loved our eco-friendly packaging! We’ve been working hard to reduce waste.”
  3. Handle negative reviews like a pro: Acknowledge the issue, offer a solution, and show you’re on it. Example: “I’m really sorry about the mix-up with your order. We’re already looking into it and will make sure it doesn’t happen again.”
  4. Get personal: Use “I” instead of “We” to make your responses feel more genuine. “I’m thrilled you had a great experience!” feels more personal than “We’re thrilled.”

And that’s a wrap! Start responding to those reviews, and watch your customer loyalty and sales skyrocket. Trust me, this is one simple change that can make a big difference.

Want to learn more? 🤓

If you want to learn more about this topic, you can dig into the nerdy details in the original marketing study.

Quote of the week 💬

"A reply to a review is a high-five in the digital world—don’t leave customers hanging."

About the author
Gabriel Mays, the Co-Founder and CEO of POPSMASH
Gabriel A. Mays
Gabriel Mays' Website
Co-Founder & CEO at POPSMASH
Before POPSMASH, Gabe was a Director at GoDaddy and founded two startups. He was also a Marine Corps Captain, serving in Iraq and Afghanistan. He lives with his wife and two kids on Cape Cod, MA.

Launch an AI quiz on Shopify in 2 minutes.

Help customers buy to increase sales & grow email subscribers.

Try it free
One-click signup with Shopify